WHAT HAS BEEN THE BEST ALTERNATIVE ROCK COMEBACK ALBUM?
Alice In Chains’ Black Gives Way to Blue was released in September 2009, 14 years after Alice In Chains’ self-titled album. This was the first Alice In Chains album to feature William DuVall on vocals, standing in for the late great Layne Staley. It was released over 3 years after the band’s 2006 reunion tour. Standout tracks include Check My Brain, Your Decision, A Looking In View, and Private Hell. The tracks Check My Brain and A Looking In View received Grammy nominations.
Soundgarden’s King Animal was released on Tuesday, 16 years after Soundgarden’s last album Down on the Upside. The album was two years in the making, as the band started working on it several months after they reunited in 2010. Standout tracks include A Thousand Days Before, Bones of Birds, Rowing, and Blood on the Valley Floor.
Stone Temple Pilots was released in May 2010, it was the band’s first album since 2001’s Shangri LA DEE DA. It was the culmination of STP’s 2008 reunion. The band were involved in a lawsuit with Atlantic Records dating back to 2008 since the band were interested in self-releasing their music, but eventually the two sides settled. Atlantic tried talking STP into getting a big name producer but the DeLeo brothers insisted on producing the album themselves. Standout tracks on this album include Take A Load Off, Maver, Between The Lines, and Fast As I Can. Between The Lines received a Grammy nomination.
Smashing Pumpkins’ Zeitgeist was released in July 2007. It was the first Pumpkins album since MACHINA I and II in 2000. Only half of the Smashing Pumpkins original lineup returned, but it was the band’s core members in Billy Corgan and Jimmy Chamberlin. This album ended up being the last to featured Chamberlin. Standout tracks include Tarantula, That’s the Way (My Love Is), United States, and Doomsday Clock.
Jane’s Addiction’s The Great Escape Artist was released in October 2011. It was the band’s first album since 2003’s Strays. The record went through various stages, with the first attempts at recording being in early 2009 with all four original Jane’s Addiction members with Trent Reznor serving as producer. The sessions fell apart, and following a reunion tour bassist Eric Avery quit the band. Duff McKagan replaced him and the band began work on their next album. McKagan left after only 6 months and was replaced by Dave Sitek from TV on the Radio. Former Jane’s Addiction bassist Chris Chaney was then brought in to complete the album. Standout tracks include Underground, Splash A Little Water On It, Words Right Out Of My Mouth, and I’ll Hit You Back.
Bush’s The Sea of Memories was released in September 2011. It was Bush’s first album since 2001′s Golden State. The album featured original Bush members Gavin Rossdale and Robin Goodridge, along with Golden State tour guitarist Chris Traynor and Corey Britz on bass. The album was originally going to be called Everything Always Now and was set for release in 2010, but Bush ended up leaving their label and writing more songs for the album. Standout tracks include The Sound of Winter, The Afterlife, The Mirror of the Signs, and All Night Doctors.
Nobody’s Daughter was released in April 2010, it was the first Hole album since 1998′s Celebrity Skin. It was a defacto Courtney Love solo record though, with co-founder/guitarist/integral songwriter Eric Erlandson not returning. Love found all new members for Hole, including guitarist Micko Larkin. Standout tracks include Samantha, Skinny Little Bitch, Honey, and Nobody’s Daughter.
For the record I’m not counting Red Hot Chili Peppers’ latest album since they never broke up, and there was only a 5 year break. Garbage’s most recent album also was not following a breakup but a period where they weren’t that active, and Screaming Trees’ Last Words was recorded in the late 90′s.








Alice. No question.
Soundgarden.
Of course.
Alice In Chains for sure, followed by Soundgarden.
Alice in Chains and Soundgarden have the stand out come back albums. But I’m gonna lean more to Soundgarden
Alice, sure.
Soundgarden by far
Soundgarden. No brainer.
Well with this name I’m going to say AIC aren’t I? But Soundgarden was ace too.
As one of the biggest STP fans you’ll ever meet, I have to say Soundgarden.
Although, it was a damn tough choice between Soundgarden and Alice. Both mindblowingly good albums.
Zeitgeist. Love that album.
Alice in Chains
Anyone with at least half a brain knows that.
@Andrei completely agree alice in chains all the way
oooo… easy Andrei.
Even though I’m a BIG AIC fan, other AIC fans seem a bit too rabid 4 my liking…
Well, since I’ve only heard BGWTB completely, my opinion is pretty much bollocks then…
Yeah I’m going with Zeitgeist because SP is my favorite band and I had been longing for 12 years for Billy to make a “metal” album again.
But Alice’s BGWTB was the one that surprised me positively the most. I did not expect such a strong album, especially given that Jerry solo does nothing for me and well… the new singer.
My 2 choices.
I voted for STP’s album, but they didn’t really do well.
personaly Bush’s new album is fresh, I think.
Surprised to see SG with a lead. AIC all the way.
really though decision between BGWTB and KA, but I’ll go this time with Alice in Chains
BGWTB was a thousand times better than KA
I am an Stp, SP, Soundgarden and Alice in Chains fan but you have to admit it: last Jane’s Addiction has got 5-6 beautiful hits. If only they had more support…
It’s hard for me to choose between King Animal and BGWTB.
Stone Temple Pilots’ album started off fine with Between The Lines; after that it was straight VH1.
BGWTB had the advantage of being surprising upon first listen (especially with a Duvall-led song). I kind of spoiled my experience with King Animal by listening to the full album multiple times before the release date. Of course BGWTB would’ve been great with Layne (it also wouldn’t have existed) but people seem to forget about Mike Starr and his bass playing stood out.
On an emotional level, I give it to AIC. Music-wise… my vote is going to Soundgarden.
Brett wrote :
“Standout tracks include A Thousand Days Before, Bones of Birds, Rowing, and Blood on the Valley Floor.”
and as my standout track are By Crooked Steps, Taree, Eyelid’s mouth and NSA, that is the proof how amazing & various KA is.
AIC comeback album is the only one who got me back 20 years, to the beginning itself. Although without Layne, the album Black Gives Way To Blue was like it has just come out of the nineties and hit me in the brain! Definitely, the most consistent come-back album, that’s for sure.
It’s pretty obvious that SG and AIC are amongst the best comebacks, but there is one album in the poll that is very underrated – Jane’s Addiction’s The Great Escape Artist is an amazing album. For me personally, it’s very hard to decide, because AIC, SG and Jane’s are almost equal. I voted vor Jane’s though, because I can’t stand the lack of appreciation for their album.
I also loved STP’s album pretty much, but it’s not as good as the other 3 mentioned above.
I definitely think King Animal is the best comeback on the list, though I also enjoy Nobody’s Daughter. I was a crazy AIC fan through middle school and high school but I was really disappointed with Black Gives Way To Blue when it came out. I like Jerry’s solo albums better. I don’t think it has to do with Layne being gone either, it’s just something else that I can’t pinpoint. I am digging King Animal though. I guess I don’t know if I can consider Nobody’s Daughter much a comeback though since after the album Courtney has just returned to being self-destructive and hasn’t been working on music much.
One more proof that KA is a good album, despite some of you wanting it to sound like an 90′s album. Move the fuck on. the year is 2012.
Alice for sure with SG a close second.
Isn’t Strays the “comeback” album from JA?
Soundgarden all the way.
Heavens to Murgatroyd!
Alice In Chains – BGWTB – Best Comeback Album. Period.
Exclamation Point Ev-vun…
^ :::Channeling Snagglepuss:::
Soundgarden I love (have not heard the new record), but honestly, they broke up by choice. Chris went on with Audioslave, and now they are back together, and that is good. He’s back where he belongs – at the heart of the original music. I love his voice and Kim’s guitar.
Jerry, Sean and Mike watched a dear brother die slowly, and of his own volition (in the beginning anyway IMHO once Heroin addiction takes hold, the drug controls the addict, not the addict controls the drug…)
Their comeback from despair, loss, and an unknown future WAS BGWTB.
Read the lyrics from *All Secrets Known*.
May the most popular record win.
Peace
Alice in Chains’s BGWTB was a huge breath of fresh air. Soundgarden’s King Animal is a good album, with many great songs, but doesn’t really stand out.
AIC – the song are memorable and heavy. Soundgarden has messed up the middle party of the album
Brett, what is your vote?
i am trying to like King Animal but i don’t know. I do like Matt and Kim work on the album.
Seems to me that a lot of people wanted Chris Cornell to change his shitty solo albums for something better (to shine) and this is better but not near Soundgarden’s trademark…is quite boring you know.
Highlights for me A thousand Days before and Bloon on the Valley Floor. For example Bones of Birds could fit in Euphoria Morning.
BGWTB in the other hand is awesome and they lost Layne, i couldn’t believe they did something amazing without him…but they did.
Both good albums (Alice and Soundgarden) but Soundgarden gets the nod. Brute force is good, but its even better when there’s some extra technical expertise in the mix as well.
and also ‘The Great escape Artist’ is awesome, check it out
i like the song tarantula but lets be honest here and not dick ride for the sake of todays music all of these albums are trash id still rather listen to all of these bands old albums.
Soundgarden #1
Alice #2
STP #3
Rest are average to fan only listening.
Truth is making an album to please everyone is impossible.
Just be glad there are still bands like these left.
By the time Pearl Jam releases their next album will that be considered a comeback album???
Everyone well almost, is saying Soundgarden because it ‘rocks’ the most. Alice in Chains did BGWTB without their original lead singer, that’s a tall task.
STP should have got a lot more love, sure the album didn’t ‘rock’ as much but to me it was more like a Blues-Rock record. I was impressed by what they pulled off.
I thought Bush and the Pumpkins also had strong records, it’s always hard to come out with a solid album when you have set the bar really high.
king animal, then Zeitgeist, then black gives way to blue, then rest do not even deserve to be mentioned!!!!
ejsme, my favorite is Stone Temple Pilots’ self-titled album. STP didn’t attempt to fall back on the sound of any of their 90′s albums, and the melodies on the album are just great. You can tell Scott Weiland still deals with a lot of depression (regarding his divorce, drinking, still dealing with his brother’s death), and it makes for really inspired music. The album also has my favorite STP song ever: Maver. That’s why I’m really pissed at STP for not announcing a followup. The thing with Scott’s problems is it makes for great music, but at the same time makes it hard for Robert, Dean, and Eric to get along with him enough to make a record.
Black Gives Way to Blue is right behind it, it’s even more impressive that Jerry was able to make such a solid album without Layne, and actually make it sound like Alice In Chains rather than a Jerry Cantrell solo record. King Animal is next on the list for me, there’s 5-6 songs I really enjoy, along with a few others that I think are pretty cool. A Thousand Days Before is on par with their old material to me and one of the great Soundgarden songs. A big reason I prefer STP and Black Gives Way to Blue though is I still hear emotional desperation on those albums (Jerry’s reaction to Layne’s downfall and death, Weiland’s depression), along with some stronger melodies. Doesn’t mean I don’t really enjoy King Animal though.
I think when it comes to which album though established a comeback the best though, I’d say Black Gives Way to Blue. The album had two huge rock radio hits and they couldn’t have done a better job making a comeback album without Layne. Well, except for maybe if they had left Take Her Out off lol.
King Animal is a very creative and sold album. Attrition has me confused because the low vocal parts sound like Lanegan, but I don’t think Lanegan is singing on it, Anyway,
Soundgarden #1
AIC #2
STP #3
Regarding the other albums, I think Hole’s Nobody’s Daughter is highly underrated. It’s better than Courtney’s solo album America’s Sweetheart and there are some very inspired songs on there. Honey, Pacific Coast Highway, Skinny Little Bitch, Never Go Hungry, Nobody’s Daughter, and Samantha. I mean ‘people like you fuck people like me, in order to avoid suffering’ and ‘I hold on to you like the death of angel/And I hold on to you with all the life that’s in me.’
Zeitgeist’s high points are great, but the low points suck. Tarantula and That’s the Way (My Love Is) are two of Corgan’s best songs in the last 10-12 years to me. Despite some shoddy vocals Doomsday Clock and United States are also really solid songs. I like 7 Shades of Black and Bleeding the Orchid alright too. But the rest of the album is pretty brutal, I mean Starz/Pomp and Circumstance/the production on For God and Country ugh. Could have been a great album with better song selection and vocal production.
The Jane’s Addiction and Bush albums are hit and miss. Underground is up there with classic Jane’s, I also enjoy Splash a Little Water On It and Words Right Out of My Mouth a lot. Broken People and End to the Lies are fine, but lack the extra punch they need to really be really good songs. Ultimate Reason, Irresistible Force, and Curiosity Kills are pretty bad. Irresistible Force has one of the most half assed/uninspired verses ever that really killed its radio potential, especially the the hooky chorus. The problem was they came up with the chorus, then had no clue what to put around it. The album only being 10 songs hurts it.
The Bush album has The Sound of Winter which is as great as any of their other hits. It has some other enjoyable songs too like All Night Doctors, All My Life, The Afterlife, and The Mirror of the Signs. There’s just too many shitty songs though like She’s a Stallion, Red Light, and a few others I forget the names of. I’m glad the album happened though for the 4-5 songs I like, especially The Sound of Winter.
Yes, it’s not the same AIC without Layne, BUT you have to admit this is not the same ‘garden either.
On King Animal:
I listened once- not too bad
I listened 10 more times- was digging it
listened 10 more times- the excitement of the album’s release wears off a bit and I can hear it for what it is…. the music isn’t the same, Chris’ voice isn’t the same, nor is his way of writing or singing the lyrics. It’s become tired, non-energetic, and really raspy, actually more like a large tooth saw.
They changed the recipe– while AIC really didn’t.. Sure they substituted margarine for butter but the amounts of the ingredients and methods stayed the same.
All these Ben Shepherd songs turned it into a Soundgarden/Hater album.
Kim’s A Thousand Days Before is the last thing I ever expected him to write. It’s sounds so cheesy even if there is some palm muted power chords mixed in. And Matt replaced hard hitting beats with wimpy little drum fills all over the place. Sure, he’s good at drums but he took the hard edge away from SG so they sound more like PJ or worst yet, the Police?? There are about 5 songs that I still really like, but I don’t know guys–I have always liked every song on their previous albums… I look forward to the tour for the older songs and the NEXT album.
On King Animal, I wasn’t looking for a “90′s album” but I wanted something on par with their “sound.” It’s interesting, but it’s like they sat down with pencils and paper and wrote how they wanted the album to sound instead of just jamming and making the new songs.
This of course is all opinion so please save all of the defense arguments. I don’t see the point in arguing about opinions when it comes to music as we all have different tastes.
with all those shits Cornell did when he was out of Soundgarden, King Animal deserves more credit for bringing the man back.. Hell he even grew his hair long, and sound awesome live.
so 1 for soundgarden.
when ever i listen BGWTB i imagine layne singing his part
I would say there have been no really good comeback albums at all.
However, Alice In Chains would be my choice from this list.
Soundgarden may or may not grow on me.
Black Gives Way to Blue obviously.
1.AIC
2.SG
3.Jane’s
4.Bush
5.Smashing
6.STP
7.Hole
SG
I’m really surprised with all the SG votes. I have the feeling people are voting because it’s Soundgarden, not because they think the album’s the best of the options. This isn’t a vote for your favorite band. The hardest thing to do as a fan is to be honest. You want an album to be great when it’s only decent, so you pretend it’s great because you don’t want to admit your favorite band is anything less than perfect.
Okay for all of you “AIC fans” who keep saying over and over and over again, “They are not the same w/o Layne” Of course AIC will not be the same, w/o Layne! They are not supposed to be the same!. Duvall said himself that he is trying to do the best Duvall that he could do. He is not trying to be Layne.
I hate to break it to you guys, but Layne is gone. I loved him too, but he is gone and is never coming back. Now you could either finally come to terms with that and move on, and enjoy the beautiful NEW music that AIC has to offer, or just wallow in sadness forever and ever.
Layne would have wanted AIC to finally continue on without him. Layne has moved onto a better place. Cherish the memories and allow the remaining living members to carry on and do what they love, which is, creating wonderful music for us!
**AIC FOREVER!!**
Well VS, to be honest AIC is my least favorite grunge band, I always prefered Nirvana SG, and Pearl Jam, so yeah I didn’t care for BGWTB.
“Hold it!!! Hold it already!!!
I Begs to Differ — I’m a Differ Beggar…” <~~~ @ 3:30
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=udVCwQzRl2I
Heavens to you-know-what…
Votes are 43 to 44% already…
Closer than The Obama-Romney Election Ev-ven…
^ LOL… Snagglepuss
This 50 year old cartoon makes my 21 month old grandson Aden LOL…
He even understands the duck.
@ Allura – Yeah, I'm with you dear. Well said.
AIC Forever
Aden recognizes Facelift, Dirt, JOF & BGWTB. Immediately.
Runs in the room grinning & starts banging his little blond head as the music starts to play. Just to please Nana.
OK – I'm gonna quit acting like a child now.
Exit — Stage Left.
Peace Ev-ven
To Vs. , you are right. I am a huge Soundgarden fan so I have to admit that it’s hard to be honest after 16 !!! years waiting a new album. But King Animal should have contained 10 songs, no more. There are things I can not accept, things that make me think about Cornell’s solo albums (Oh my god, what a waste of time, such a shame). So let’s be honest. King Animal has the advantages to be the most waited album and to be just went out.
Soundgarden’s King Animal is definitely the best record on this list by far. It is the most creative and diverse. Every song on this record sounds different and that is what makes it a phenomenal album. Black Gives Way to Blue is very good but lacks in musical complexity and in experimentation compared to King Animal. Soundgarden in my mind, is a better band than Alice in Chains. STP’s new album fucking blows as does Scott Weiland who is nothing more than a Diva and a David Bowie rip off ( I am sorry Brett but its true ). I really have enjoyed Bush’s new album a lot as I like Gavin’s voice. As for the other three albums I have not heard enough of them to judge.
1, King Animal
2, BGWTB
3, The Sea of Memories
Addition to last comment,
New and in Newest albums.
@Cornell Forever I’d like to know your definition of “creative and diverse” and “experimentation.” All the knocks on King Animal that I’ve read are because the album lacks these things, and I agree. Listen to the album and what do you hear? You hear Soundgarden, just like they’ve always sounded, just not quite as good.
Wow, Cornell Forever, I don’t think I can call you an idiot. We need a new name for you. Suggestions anyone?
@Andrei
Why thank you for the kind words. I respect a lot of your opinions on this site but why do always have to be such a cunt!… LOL
Brett, thanks for saying GREAT “….the late great Layne Staley” – I have issues because after all this time, I still ain’t over it.
I think there should be another choice:
All the comeback albums are inferior to previous works.
I would go for that one as it is true. I guess something is better than nothing…
@Cornell Forever Stop respecting my opinions as I obviously don’t like yours.
Scott Weiland blows and he’s nothing more than a David Bowie rip-off? Is this 1992 all over again?
And don’t even get me started on how BGWTB lacks musical complexity. Are you fucking insane? KA is the one-dimensional one, pure boredom, goes absolutely nowhere.
Good point. KA is pretty much one dimensional. There is a trend here though. Does a “great” comeback album exist? These albums listed above may be good, but I wouldn’t call any of them great (I’ve only heard the Hole album twice and wouldn’t listen to Bush if you paid me, so I don’t have an educated opinion on these two).
It seems the comeback album gets the bands’ feet back in the water, which opens up for greatness on their follow-up. The perfect example of this is Zeitgeist to Oceania. Zeitgeist was average, Oceania is near perfect.
KA by a mile. It’s the Album of the year and the last 16 years. KA shit kicks that Jerry solo crap. BlacknBlue is loaded with filler and lame ballads. Check your brain people.
@Grungy,are you fucking mental
@Andrei
BGWTB is a good record but lacks in originality as it tends to sound like a Jerry Cantrell solo album at times. KA is FULL of new sounds that we have not heard before from these guys (Examples being Black Saturday, Worse Dreams and Rowing) If you compare the two records musically, Soundgarden’s playing compared to AIC’s is more complex and dynamic. Chris is a better singer than William and Jerry and Matt is a better drummer than Sean. Soundgarden in my view, are a better band than AIC but AIC is still great. Aside from maybe BGWTB, name me a another track on that ablum that REALLY stands out from the rest of them?
“KA is the one-dimensional one, pure boredom, goes absolutely nowhere.” Are YOU fucking insane!?!? I can see now why you are a fan of Scott Weiland. You need to check your head.
@Cornell Forever you said (Aside from maybe BGWTB, name me
a another track on that ablum that REALLY stands out from
the rest of them?)are you insane
to just name one lesson learned
When I listen to STP album, it sounds to me like the creative process lasted two weeks. Instead KA two years. But the final product is quite similar…they both are ok but not awesome
Without Layne, it just isn’t Alice in Chains. No one can take the place of Mr. Staley.
I’m going to go with AiC on this one. Private Hell alone is enough to get my vote. Very underrated song. I thought the entire album was good overall but that song escalated the album to another level for me. I’m reading that BGWTB lacks complexity. Well IMO Private Hell was one of the most complex songs this band has put out.
KIng Animal is my favorite album of all time. GREAT album. Eyelid’s Mouth, Taree, Non-State Actor, Worse Dreams, Been Away Too Long, Rowing. If i keep on listing my favorite songs you will just end up with the whole tracklist except Halfway There. I wouldnt even think this vote would be between KA and BGWTB because BGWTB is pure and total SHIT. a few good songs but a lot that seems like filler to me. I like Check My Brain, Last Of My Kind, and Lesson Learned but the rest is ver mediocre. STP is better than BGWTB but King Animal is the best EVER
@Josh
“Private Hell was one of the most complex songs this band has put out.”
My Favorite, followed by Last of My Kind, and then BGWTB. The whole record is special, and only 11 songs.
I am really looking forward to the new record.
AIC Forever
@ Brett
“Well, except for maybe if they had left Take Her Out off lol.”
Why? Was it too *poppy* in your opinion? Why do you dislike that song?
I am just curious.
Thanks in advance if you respond.
@Josh
Same here , plus Private Hell totally have that AIC feel , it has this ” Down In A Hole ” flavour
Leave your response!
Archives
Buy Us A Mocha
Recent Comments
Most Commented