Home » Featured, Smashing Pumpkins

JAMES IHA SAYS HIS SOLO ALBUM LET IT COME DOWN CAN STAND NEXT TO SMASHING PUMPKINS’ MELLON COLLIE

By: 2 January 2013 21 Comments

UPDATE: It looks like the meaning of what some of James said could have been lost in translation.

Here is an excerpt from SPFreaks‘ new interview with former Smashing Pumpkins guitarist James Iha:

“At the time I also wrote my own songs. Barely a handful were released under The Smashing Pumpkins moniker. And that didn’t bother me. Everything had to fit in with the larger view of the albums and the band. Songs which we worked on because they might have appeared on Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness were fortunately not recorded. They received their own place on my solo debut, Let It Come Down. That album can effortlessly – and on its own – stand next to the monumental masterpiece that we created as The Smashing Pumpkins. With Look to the Sky, I have the feeling that there doesn’t need to be any talk of it ‘existing alongside’. Now the album is one with me and my whole life right now; an expression of what I am doing at this very moment and want to share with the world. In this harmony, I can play my songs mixed in with songs I cherish, whether they’re covers of Patti Smith, or ‘Mayonaise’ which Billy Corgan and I wrote, which I see as an absolute highlight from my time with The Smashing Pumpkins. That I can entertain people all the way over here in the The Netherlands, fills me with gratitude and happiness. “

21 Comments »

  • Alternadude said:

    Yeah well I love his album but no comparizon possible with the greatest album of all time that is Mellon Collie.

  • Sonic_Junkie said:

    Please, James. Please.

  • Dondo said:

    This is all translated from Dutch. I think something got lost in translation with that line in particular. Also, he doesn’t usually speak with that kind of “flowery” vocabulary… I definitely think the translator embellished. Understandable – its difficult thing to pull off.

  • Dondo said:

    Wait – I’m wrong. It was not translated. Nevermind! Funny he said that.

  • versus said:

    Sorry, James. Your first album wasn’t awful by any means, but as good as MCIS? Not even close, but I like your confidence.

  • Butthead said:

    No wonder Billy hates James Iha so much…

  • Mayonaise said:

    James’ solo work is great and I’m a fan of it, but it’s just not in the same category as MCIS. Let It Come Down and Look to the Sky are both great albums, but they’re more soft and indie and just are in a different category than MCIS, which is basically a loosely formed rock opera.

  • Wbcn1041 said:

    Hahahahahaha.

  • Craigory52 said:

    I guess I’ll listen to it and hear what it is like but come on now…Mellon Collie? That’s a masterpiece.

  • thefreewheelinmarkarm said:

    I feel a shitstorm a-brewing. I can’t wait for the BillCo retaliation on that one.

  • Arthur said:

    In the context of the total interview I read the complete opposite. (…) and play its humble role in music history.

  • ThemBoners said:

    ha ha, I remember Billy said that Iha only composed “a few chords” for Mayonaise…

    which is actually the best SP song of all time, in my opinion

  • King of Gloom said:

    You twisted his words. He does say that Let It Come Down can exist next to MCIS, but the way you say it, it seems that his solo album is on par with Mellon Collie. He didn’t say that.

  • Keith said:

    He needs to lay off the crack pipe…

  • Is he one? said:

    James just tweeted that:

    James Iha – Official ?@James_Iha
    Nice interview w/ SPFreaks but something (a lot) got lost in translation…It’s funny!! But not my words unfortunately.

  • sarah said:

    Apparently not his words according to twitter…doesn’t sound like him either.
    @James_Iha
    Nice interview w/ SPFreaks but something (a lot) got lost in translation…It’s funny!! But not my words unfortunately.

  • satan said:

    yes!

    country girl by James Iha is the best song ever!

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ftHZIi5MXIA

  • Is he one? said:

    @Satan
    For some reason I’m pretty sure you were being sarcastic. And obviously it isn’t the “best song ever”, but it is a very good song in my opinion. I’ve been listening to this whole album regularly since 1997. Its really got something unique, a tremendous beauty.

  • DP said:

    James himself has said the interview was lost in translation. He’s not claiming that at all.

  • Millz said:

    I saw SP once. Worst concert ever. Holy fuck they were awful.

  • Fabien said:

    Why did you have to do that, Grunge Report ? James is just saying he’s proud of his solo album as much as he’s proud of Mellon Collie, that’s all.

Leave your response!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.