BILLY CORGAN REVEALS WHY HE FIRED SMASHING PUMPKINS DRUMMER JIMMY CHAMBERLIN
On Rockline last night Billy Corgan finally revealed the reason that he fired original Smashing Pumpkins drummer Jimmy Chamberlin last year.
Billy said that he has always been the one to choose the direction of the band, even if others disagreed. He said that he and Jimmy had a disagreement about the future of the band. He said that the disagreement had been long standing, and Billy said it was nothing he was going to fight over. He said “not all band members live in reality” but he lives in today’s music world reality. He said he’s determined to move the Smashing Pumpkins forward with new music. He also said he doesn’t want to be an oldies band taking money to pay his bills, he wants to be an artist to be an artist. He said Jimmy wanted to shut things down and make things simpler, and become an oldies act.









I can see Billy’s point but at the same time I can also see that of Jimmy’s. Everyone has bills to pay and who can blame Jimmy for wanting to make a quick buck (he is only human after all). If this really is the case I feel it should of been kept inhouse to protect the reputaion of a great musician.
Good luck to both in future because they deserve any success that comes their way.
HA! What was that about not everyone living in reality?
I bet jimmy’s vision of the band was more down in reality than billy’s
Fail. Revisionist history at it’s best.
OK Bill, so WHO wasn’t living in reality?
Roboface is right. Billy is a revisionist if there ever was one. Bottom line: Jimmy is one of the greatest drummers ever. Period.
“Billy said that he has always been the one to choose the direction of the band, even if others disagreed.”
It’s stuff like this that really makes the whole concept of “Smashing Pumpkins” a joke nowadays, and I say that as a huge fan who only got into them after the “reunion.” That’s not a band, it’s a dictatorship. It’d be foolish to deny that he has always been THE guy in Smashing Pumpkins but if that’s the case, that he is the sole determinant of where the band goes, then using the Smashing Pumpkins name is just as “oldies” as what Jimmy suggested. If he really wants to stop living in the past and move forward and be an artist for the sake of being an artist, drop the name and show us what you’ve got when you’re not hiding behind a brand that relies heavily on nostalgia to find its audience.
On a semi-related note, I hate how the semantics of “Smashing Pumpkins” means that he’ll never perform Zwan songs, some of which were fantastic. Pound for pound, Zwan > SP.
I think Jimmy, James and D’arcy should get together and find another singer, and create NEW music that will blow away anything SP has done in the last decade.
Im seriously sick of his babbling about being an “oldies act”,”living in the past” blablabla.
I heard the Rockline interview and i honestly don’t know what the fuck wanting to become an “oldies act” is supposed to mean on Jimmy’s part. Or _his _ part.
Let me guess. BC strummed a couple of pretty boring and aimless song structures asking JC what he thought.
JC probably squirmed awkwardly and said “Uhm,i dunno. It doesn’t hit me like Bullet With Butterfly Wings did or any other song you wrote way back which was really good” The great BC frowned upon his insolence.
The thing i can’t stand about BC’s music nowadays is simply that it isn’t very good and that i’m supposed to consider it as good as the pre 1997 stuff,and that from his point of view, I ,the fan simply do not see their greatness due to clamouring for the past.
I dont want him to make “Siamese Dream II” or “Mellon Collie II”. However i DO want him to use the sense of emotion and creativity he employed during those albums. It is NOT there now.
All i see is some well off dude in his 40′s with no sense of handling critique,stumbling around his growing collection of vintage studio gear with a bunch of mindless yaysayers courting to him.
He keeps returning to the subject on sounding like “it’s 1993 again”.
So,it’s ok to (terribly) emulate Jon Lord (I’m talking to you,stupid keyboard part in various songs) and various aspects of 60′s-70′s bands and pretend that you were “inspired” by it.
I can accept that from some basement musician discovering his roots and playing around with it in hope of evolving his songwriting but not from a world renowned artist who already has created a viable platform for himself.
I’m sure those sources of inspiration popped up during the early 90s during the recording of said albums,but when they did,they flowed effortless and seamlessly together with his own ideas.
Billy does not have enough people around him who don’t give a fuck about who he is and can tell him what works and what doesn’t.
I strongly believe that the “industry” that gave him such a hard time actually pulled out the best of him and guided him in some parts to the great results which occurred with albums such as “Siamese Dream” and “Mellon Collie”.
He does not seem to understand that his muse was never creating art in hope of a cathartic result in dealing with his past but rather creating art under adversity.
In other words he did his best work when he was pressured to follow up Gish with an even better album and doubting his ability he thought “fuck it,i’ll try”.
The Industry frowned upon his idea on making a double album viable for the masses,something very few had done before.
He said “fuck it we’ll try”.
The problem here is that there are no such challenges for him to face.
Plus,i think he’s spent way to much time in L.A. That’s just my 2 cents. Bye now.
I like the idea of the Ex-Smashing Pumpkins bandmates of getting together that would be a great idea.
Chamberlin is making entirely new music with a new band – whereas Billy is still touring on a set of songs, with more than half of them from the band’s 15-20 year old albums. That Billy Corgan is being an oldies act. You fail Corgan, you really do.
am I wrong, or was the press release of Jimmy leaving stated as thought he QUIT because of musical differences? Billy even said that Jimmy gave him his blessing to continue on with the SP name. Was that all bullshit, or is this bullshit?
The new SP album “Oceania” is actually better than “Zietgeist,” “Adore,” or “Machina.” All the haters should just find another band to like. NIN is Trent Reznor. Filter is Richard Patrick. Smashing Pumpkins is Billy Corgan. Get used to it or move on.
Leave your response!
Archives
Buy Us A Mocha
Recent Comments
Most Commented